Showing posts with label Characters. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Characters. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 13, 2011

Henry James Grows A Beard

A few weeks ago, Mighty Reader and I discussed my contention that to create believable characters, a writer must love his characters wholly, exactly the way they are. A writer must not judge his characters--even the bad ones--or they will become objects instead of people. A writer must accept everything about his characters and must love a character's shortcomings as much as he loves that character's strengths.

In my work, I don't think in terms of hero/villain. I don't present a main character who has a flaw to recognize and overcome. I also don't think in terms of good/bad, not really. I don't really think of protagonist/antagonist either, though certainly I have people acting in opposition to one another. What I have is sort of a sliding scale of moral and ethical failures. Just like real life. I think this keeps my stories from becoming melodrama or morality plays, where good is rewarded and evil is punished. In my stories, things happen between people because of who they are, not necessarily because of where they're situated relative to my personal moral compass. At least I try to do that.

I'll attempt to speak more concretely. Suppose I have two characters, Shelly and Davy. Shelly loves puppies. She adores them. She'll give up her own dinner so that a puppy can eat. Davy, on the other hand, despises puppies. He hates their loose skin and big eyes and waggly tails. Passionately.

It would be easy to set Shelly up as a good guy/hero figure and Davy as a bad guy/villain. But what I would want to do is to empathize with each of them in the same way, to show that each character's feelings about puppies are perfectly reasonable and valid responses to the world for those characters. I would allow myself, when writing about Davy, to think of puppies as unruly, vile and wriggly beasts that foul their beds and yap all night and disobey all commands or whatever. I would think of something I didn't like and map those feelings onto the fictional Davy's dislike of those horrific yowly monstrosities puppies. I would take Davy's hatred of puppies seriously, and respect his worldview rather than mock it. (Though all bets are off if I'm writing a comedy.)

For the record, I like puppies.

Anyway, I am approaching a couple of scenes in my work-in-progress where the characters to be examined hold personal beliefs that I find absolutely repugnant, but I owe it to them (and, not incidentally, to my readers) to not condemn or comment upon these sets of beliefs. I owe it to the truth I'm seeking as a writer to give full vent to whatever my characters feel, and to stay as much out of their way as I can. Real live intelligent educated people have ideas that I think are stupid and poorly thought out, but I have to present their fictional counterparts the way they see themselves, as intelligent educated people. I have to love them for what they are, unconditionally.

The title of this post is a joke for Rick Daley.

Wednesday, December 29, 2010

Do your characters sound different?

I'm keeping this short since I'm throwing it out to you rather than talking about it myself. Are you able to create characters that sound different when they speak? This is something I don't think about very much as I write, and I'm wondering if anyone has any tips.

I'm curious to know:

1. what techniques you use to make your characters sound different and

2. if you, as a reader, are bothered when characters DON'T sound different.

Monday, December 20, 2010

Your characters offstage

Do you keep track of what your characters do offstage?

In many of my stories, I follow multiple people, through multiple times. I love epics, and I've always dreamed of successfully writing one. But, one of the biggest challenges to writing an epic isn't only keeping track of my characters when I'm writing about them. I also have to keep track of my characters when I'm not writing about them.

Has Veronica been away for six months while I'm writing about Markus and Sissy? Well, what has Veronica been doing?

I'm sometimes successful at keeping track of the offstage characters, but then there's the added challenge of figuring out how that time offstage has affected them emotionally. If Veronica was fuming mad at Markus before leaving for a year-long sabbatical in Zurich, is she still fuming mad when she returns? Or, has the time away made her forget her anger, or at least push it down into the pit of her belly so that she can seek her revenge more systematically?

For me, the best epic writers (ahem, Tolstoy) are able to account for offstage characters and their continued emotional journeys, even though we as readers don't experience it directly. This skill not only makes the characters seem more believable, but it also helps to make the world of your fiction more believable.

Oddly enough, the time when your character isn't on the stage is also an opportunity to develop them.

This weekend I watched The King's Speech written by David Seidler, and one of the vital details about Albert, the protagonist, was that he would make a better king than his older brother. The audience doesn't get to see exactly why Albert would make a better king, but based on the other characters' opinions of him, we assume that he has proven himself offstage.

I'm currently dealing with a similar situation in my current book. I'm trying to portray seven characters that are much wiser than I am, and to do that, I'm making claims that their wisdom has shown through during times that I don't actually write about. I support this by having other characters chime in about their wisdom, a technique that helps to support many character details.

We may jump through time to keep from having to include unimportant details that happen between important scenes, but that doesn't mean we can't make those spaces work for us.

Do you have an example of great things your characters did offstage? What do you do to keep track of it all?

Tuesday, November 30, 2010

Writing Advice From Agatha Christie

Well, not really advice per se, but this is some good stuff Christie wrote in the introduction to her novel Passenger to Frankfurt. I loved it, and I thought it worth sharing.

The Author speaks:

The first question put to an author, personally, or through the post, is, "Where do you get your ideas from?"

The temptation is great to reply, "I always go to Harrods," or "I get them mostly at the Army & Navy Stores," or, snappily, "Try Marks and Spencer."

The universal opinion seems firmly established that there is a magic source of ideas which authors have discovered how to tap. One can hardly send one's questioner back to Elizabethan times, with Shakespeare's

Tell me, where is fancy bred,
Or in the heart or in the head,
How begot, how nourished?
Reply, reply.


You merely say firmly, "My own head."

That, of course, is no help to anybody. If you like the look of your questioner, you relent and go a little further.

"If one idea in particular seems attractive, and you feel you could do something with it, work it up, tone it down, and gradually get it into shape. Then, of course, you have to start writing it. That's not nearly such fun--it becomes hard work. Alternatively, you can tuck it carefully away, in storage, for perhaps using in a year or two years' time."

A second question--or rather a statement--is then likely to be, "I suppose you take most of your characters from real life?"

"No, I don't. I invent them. They are mine. They've got to be my characters--doing what I want them to do, being what I want them to be--coming alive for me, having their own ideas sometimes, but only because I've made them become real."

So the author has produced the ideas, and the characters--but now comes the third necessity--the setting. The first two come from inside sources, but the third is outside--it must be there--waiting--in existence already. You don't invent that--it's there--it's real.

You have been perhaps for a cruise on the Nile--you remember it all--just the setting you want for this particular story. You have had a meal at a Chelsea cafe. A quarrel was going on--one girl pulled out a handful of another girl's hair. An excellent start for the book you are going to write next. You travel on the Orient Express. What fun to make it the scene for a plot you are considering. You go to tea with a friend. As you arrive, her brother closes a book he is reading--throws it aside and says, "Not bad, but why on earth didn't they ask Evans?"

So you decide immediately a book of yours shortly to be written will bear the title, Why Didn't They Ask Evans? You don't know yet who Evans is going to be. Never mind. Evans will come in due course--the title is fixed.

[I know that Christie's comments about setting won't apply to those of you who write SF/F, but a lot of this rings true for me. Discuss.]

Tuesday, November 2, 2010

The Wrong End of the Telescope

A writer I know was telling me about some trouble he had once with a novel. It seems that the protagonist, despite my writer friend's best efforts, would not come into focus for the reader. He was a shadowy, vague figure who resisted my friend's efforts to see him clearly.

"I just couldn't figure out who this guy was," he said. "It's like he was invisible."

Predictably, my writer friend complained about his troubles to his wife. "No matter how hard I try, I just can't see my main character. He's like this fixed point around which all the action of the story moves, but he himself is always out-of-focus."

"Maybe that's the problem," his wife said. "He's a fixed point. He's not really a character."

"Huh," said my writer friend.

"Maybe," his wife continued, "If he was a character in someone else's story, you could see him better. You could figure out who he is."

"Maybe," my writer friend said.

"Why don't you write the story from the point of view of the villain--the antagonist guy? You know him pretty well, right? If you have to look at your protagonist as a moving object--a character, you know--in the antagonist's story, you'll have to flesh him out, won't you? You'll have to make him 3-dimensional, I think."

And she was exactly right, and that's exactly what my writer friend did: he thought about the novel as being more from the antagonist's point of view. For the first time he really looked at his protagonist from the outside and could see who he was and what made him tick. The novel got a whole lot better when he rewrote it, and was eventually sold and published and my writer friend is working on another book now.


Also! You Americans out there! Don't forget to vote!


Thursday, October 28, 2010

Whom Do You Hate? Er...Unlove? Strongly Dislike...

I received an email from a reader, Lindsay Samuels, a few days ago asking us to plug her site, and I must say it's worth plugging. She's pursuing a degree in Library Science (no easy task, I assure you) and has a site up which is informative and entertaining. Her latest post is great - 50 Most Hated Characters in Literary History. 

Lindsay begins the post with the disclaimer that literature is highly subjective art. Yeah, we all know about that around here, don't we?

I found it interesting and disturbing that the 1st hated characters on Lindsay's list were Twilight's Edward and Bella. Following in the list are Beth March from Little Women, Hamlet from Shakespeare, and Robert Langdon from the Dan Brown novels. I liked Lindsay's little blurb about him:
Historical and religious inaccuracies aside, one of the biggest complaints that readers had against Robert Langdon is his veritable Mary Sue status. The man can do no wrong and has no discernable flaws, making him exceptionally boring and frustrating to read about.
Ah, so true.

Lindsay's article is a fun read. You should check it out. And if you don't see a character you hate (or love to hate...) in the list, add them here! And tell us why. It might be fun to compile our own list of hated characters and put it up somewhere alongside our most loved characters (we'll save that for another day).

One character I strongly dislike is Becky Sharp from Vanity Fair because the reader spends a good portion of the book rooting for her only to see her turn into a scheming, devious murdering (murdering is debatable) liar. That wouldn't be so bad if one views it all as her position as a woman in that time period - and that her terrible deeds are all crimes of circumstance (haha) - but the fact that she never truly loves her child and remains un-devoted to him at all is what makes her unlovable to me. I love the book, though. Go figure. I do think the fact that Becky is unlovable in so many ways makes her an admirable tool in the literary work. We can save that for another day, too.


Tuesday, October 26, 2010

Character Change, or Discovery?

I was talking recently to Domey about one of his stories, and we were discussing the idea of character change. It occurred to me that, possibly, I don't actually believe in change. I don't believe in "developing characters." I know, this flies in the face of conventional wisdom, but bear with me. This isn't a revolution; I'm not offering to throw out character arcs, but I have maybe a different way to think about character arcs.

So there's a general expectation for a lot of fiction that the protagonist will have a different worldview at the end of the story than he has at the start of the story. The protagonist will have changed. Usually in genre fiction this is couched in terms of character growth. Often in literary fiction this is couched in terms of the character learning a bitter lesson about life. Either way, external forces come to bear upon the protagonist and he seems to change.

The character in question in Domey's story was not the protagonist, but Domey still needed to find a way to justify what looked like a dramatic shift in his behavior. Which got me thinking about the idea of character change.

My current theory is that characters don't actually change. The way they are at the end of the story--the endpoint of the character arc to which we're moving--is actually no more and no less than how the character really is, already. His true self, if you will, is already there, but it is hidden or repressed somehow. The dramatic action, the primary conflict of the story, is created because the protagonist is unable to express that true self. Or, it can only be resolved once the protagonist expresses that true self.

Yeah, this sounds very much like new-age bullshit, but I think it's a useful intellectual construct. Let's attempt to illustrate what I mean by falling back upon that ancient tale of the hero's transformative journey: George Lucas' Star Wars.

Star Wars (by which I mean the original film, not any of the five awful sequels/prequels) tells the story of Luke Skywalker. Luke does not know it, but his true self is a Jedi Knight, a guy who is attuned to the primal energies of the universe and a force for good. Hey, that's pretty cool. The trouble is, Luke's true self is wrapped in layers of adolescent snottiness and annoying low self-esteem and a kind of general stupidity about life. The character arc of Star Wars is Luke learning to shut the hell up and accept that some folks are smarter and more experienced than he is and that life is about more than his desire to go fly rocket fighters. He is only able to destroy the Death Star at the end of the film (and resolve the outer dramatic arc of the story) when he listens to the disembodied voice of Sir Alec Guinness: "Let go your conscious self; trust your feelings." Luke lets the Force take over, becomes a Jedi and blows up the bad guys. The end. He has not changed at all; his behavior has changed. Luke has stopped acting like someone who he is not.

I sidestep the entire Aristotelian debate about whether action is in fact character and say that "we are what we do" is not as true as "we are why we do." Motivation is everything, and what motivates a character is her true self.

So think about that and see if it's helpful with your own stories. Let me know if you think this is a Bad Idea or just completely off-base and nutty.

Wednesday, August 18, 2010

The Asymptotic Approach To Character Change

A few weeks ago I was working on my novella, Bread, and I mentioned to Michelle and Scott that I only had one more scene to write! (Yay for me!) This scene was close to the end, but it wasn't the climactic scene of the story--I had already written that. Instead, it was a scene describing internal character change, the change that led to the climax.

Although this is a bit of an oversimplification, let's just say that I needed to have my character fall in love. This character had already met the man he was to fall in love with, but the chemistry wasn't quite there yet.

I had them couple go on multiple dates.

The seducer tried his best moves.

Nothing.

Even though more scenes were being added to the story, the scene, the scene of change, wasn't taking place. My character got closer and closer to the change, and then, POOF!, he was on the other side, right at the already-written climax, having made the change already.

I tried to write forwards. I tried to write backwards. But, as close as I got to the change, I never figured out a way to show it.

Wait. What did I just say? Oh yeah, show. I wasn't able to show it. One of the rules I had set for myself with Bread was that I was going to show as much as I possibly could and tell as little as I possibly could. (This was a reaction to my past fiction, and to the work of Virginia Woolf, which has a ton of beautiful telling.)

So, there I am, show-show-showing like a madman, but I couldn't show any character change. Weeks passed. Yes, Michelle, yes, Scott, I still only have one more scene to write, now stop pestering me!

I asked myself, "What does character change look like?"

I can imagine it in a movie. It's that scene where the camera zooms in on a character, let's call her Academy Award nominee Gabourey Sidibe for convenience, and we watch her as absolutely nothing happens. Did you catch it? Did you notice the internal change? No? Oh yeah, it's internal.

So, I'm wondering at you all if it's possible to show character change. Have you ever read or written a scene that actually shows it? Or, could it be that the best we can do is approach the change without actually getting to it? Now, naturally we have alternatives. We can tell. That's a personal favorite of mine. Or, we can have the change manifest in some tangible action that reflects the change. And, maybe that's good enough. But, I found myself ever so frustrated that I couldn't catch the exact moment.

Have you managed to show the time of internal character change? Is the suicidal leap the decision, or is it the action immediately after the decision?


Tuesday, August 17, 2010

When Are Characters Off Limits?

One of the conversations going on in the literary world concerns the book The Help by Kathryn Stockett. This book chronicles the lives of black domestic servants in the American south during the early 1960s. It's a pretty popular book, a popular "book club" selection and it's been on the best-seller lists for months now.

Stockett is a white woman who wrote in the voices of black women. Stockett was never a black maid; her family employed a black maid. Stockett is from the south, and like the main white character in The Help, moved to New York City to make her fortune. The Help (which I have not read) discusses topics of racism and privilege in America.

There is much discussion going on about the authenticity--or not--of Stockett's portrayals of the black women in this book. There is much discussion about whether or not Stockett even had the right to write this book with these characters, and there have been questions asked about how well this book would have been received by its primarily white readership if it had been written by a black woman.

So this is all pretty thorny. But it gets at some questions that interest me as a writer (and as a human being in the 21st century).

First, and possibly most importantly, should writers be forbidden from writing about people who they are not, and from writing about experiences that are not their own?

This seems like a foolish question, I know, because to write fiction is to write about people who are not us and events that are not ours. But if, as has been said in the discussion surrounding The Help, Stockett had no right to portray her black servant characters because she knows nothing of their real lives, then what are Stockett's choices? Does Stockett then only have the right to write about herself and people exactly like her? How different from the writer can a character be before the writer has gone too far and no longer has the right to portray them? Are we only allowed to write fantasy set in fantasy worlds, or maybe only memoirs? Either write about none but ourselves, or about people who could never have existed in real life? This seems like a reductio ad absurdum, and maybe it is, but really I think it gets to the heart of the matter. Or one of the matters, that is.

The flip side of this is that people of color and other minority status are under-represented in published fiction. And some folks take umbrage that a white writer's version of these black voices is getting published while plenty of talented black women can't get a book deal, just because they write black fiction. Whatever that is. Likely the situation in real life is more complex than that, and I don't pretend to know how many well-written manuscripts are turned down every year because publishers are afraid to publish "black fiction" or "Portuguese fiction" or "gay fiction" or "Native American fiction" or whatevs. I just don't know. I do know that publishers are afraid, and that they claim (and maybe it's true) that fiction of color sells less well than nice white books for nice white folks. We're all aware of and horrified by, I hope, the "whitewashing" of recent book covers. So there is an understandable amount of frustration and anger about the short shrift folks of color and genders-not-male are getting from the publishing world (though I believe it's also true that the majority of novels published in America these days are written by women--married white women with kids living in middle America, mostly).

I understand that most portrayals--in English-language literature, at least--of people of color, of women, of differently-oriented people have been the products of white Europeans. I understand that a lot of those characters have been portrayed as cliches: patronizingly, shallowly, insensitively and otherwise badly. A lot of stuff in the canon is frankly indefensible. But I also understand that writing fiction is, in some ways, in the best fiction, an attempt to understand. I resist the idea that we are only allowed to write about "people like us." Junot Diaz' Pulitzer Prize-winning novel is peopled mostly by Dominicans. Oscar La Valle's Big Machine is peopled mostly by African Americans. Juhmpa Lahiri's books are peopled mostly by Indian immigrants in America. Yes, I get the authenticity of voice, but need we exclude other voices? Does a Chinese woman get to write about a white guy from Baltimore? Who owns all these voices? Don't we, as writers, own every human voice? I don't know. It gives me a headache.

I've heard often enough in the context of this discussion that I, as a white male, am so inured to the background culture of white European maleness that I can't even imagine what it's like to be outside that or how that background culture marginalizes anyone not a white male. Which may be a fair cop. I wouldn't know, of course. Being a white European male and all. But if that's true, what are my options? Just stay the hell out of publishing because my kind have written enough books and now it's everyone else's turn? I really have to say that I hate that solution. Possibly I like it from an abstract ethical standpoint, but as a guy who wants to be a published novelist, I really hate it. So like everyone else, my ethics are bound by my selfishness, and my selfishness is usually more persuasive than my ethics.

Anyway. I confess that I don't know where the moral high ground is here. I think I can tell the difference between exploitation and exploration. I also think that as writers, we exploit friends and strangers all the time, cannibalizing their lives for our art. Stealing the souls of folks whose portraits we paint, as it were. I'm not going to delete the runaway slaves from my book "Cocke & Bull" nor will I delete the women from "Killing Hamlet" nor will I shy away from the POV of Lord Tilton's daughter in the book about Antarctica I'll be writing, or from the POVs of the Italian soprano or the Czech architect's wife in "The Builder's Wife," which is the book I'll write after the Antarctica book. I'm going to write all of these characters, because a bunch of books populated by only white guys like me would be even more unrealistic (and horrible, honestly) than books with whatever mistakes I'll make writing all these other folks. And I'm not going to quit writing novels, either.

I've rambled long enough. On to the questions: Are characters outside of our social/economic/gender/race groups off-limits to us as writers? Why or why not? Also, have I simply mistaken what the arguments are surrounding race/gender/etc in fiction?

Monday, July 12, 2010

Two Characters. Two Reactions.

First, I have to toot my own horn today. I found out this weekend that a short story I published in the Los Angeles Review ("Red Man, Blue Man") was selected by the editor to be used as an example of narrative tension in her fiction writing class. I'm honored!

This has put me into a great mood, so I just thought I would talk about something that always excites me when I'm writing.

One writing situation I love finding myself in is when two of my characters are forced to react to the same issue. I've been working on a story called "Satellites", and a father and daughter are both dealing with the return of a long lost family member. They go to have lunch with this family member together, but afterwards, I plan to have them react to his return in different ways..ways I have yet to figure out.

For me, this is when characters come to life. And, come to think of it, the situation arises in "Red Man, Blue Man" when each of the men decide that it's time to fall in love. What better way to emphasize individual personalities than to have them react differently to a shared situation? It was actually this very type of thing that made me start writing in the omniscient point of view, where I could get into the heads of both characters at once.

In the movie High Noon, there is a scene near the end--spoiler alert--when the main protagonist's wife (played by Grace Kelly) and his ex-lover (Katy Jurado) find themselves sitting next to each other on a train headed out of town.









Both of them have reasons for staying and reasons for leaving, but their personalities determine what each of them does in the end.

A similar situation is set up in the movie Princess Mononoke --spoiler--when two of the animal gods find themselves waiting for death.


One of the gods decides to face death calmly while the other is full of rage. Just thinking about this type of set up makes my mouth water!

Have you found yourself in this type of writing situation? Did you use it as an opportunity to contrast your characters and bring them to life?

Wednesday, June 9, 2010

The Best Characters Are Always Stubborn

When I think back on which characters in literature are the most memorable and exciting for me, the one trait I find in common with all of them is that they are stubborn.

What do I mean by stubborn?

Anna Karenina (it seems like forever since I've talked about Tolstoy!), Mahlke from Cat and Mouse, Brod from Everything Is Illuminated, Lena from Light In August, Ann from After Ann--whether it be their beauty, their penis size, their determination, their vileness, or the extent of their menstrual cramps, all of these fictional people have some part of them that doesn't conform to the norms set up by the book they participate in.

In fact, critic Harold Bloom puts it this way when he's talking about Shakespearean characters like Hamlet, Bottom, or Falstaff: The work that these characters are in aren't able to contain them.

When I say a character is stubborn, I mean they aren't willing to fit neatly into the story you have created around them. Do you want them to go down the dark basement so that the monster will have a chance to eat them? Do you want them to forget to look both ways before crossing the street? A memorable character doesn't give a flying frick about what you want! She or he doesn't care about your themes or your foils or your three act structure. She or he is going to do whatever the hell she or he wants to do because that is how vital they are...that is how stubborn they are.

One of my favorite writers today is Khuzali Manickavel. Her short story "Because Sometimes It Is Magic And Sometimes It is Everything Else" makes my mouth water every time I think about it. The story makes me feel like an utter failure in every way.

Needless to say, I have studied her writing extensively, and the one thing I've picked up from this is that a vital character and a pre-planned plot rarely if ever go hand in hand. A truly vital character will drive your story and take it to unexpected places.

Isn't there a term for that?

Many writers in the literary realm consider their work to be character driven. But, often the characters in those "character driven" stories aren't very memorable at all. I don't mean this in a bad way, since this category includes some of my other favorite writers like Jhumpa Lahiri and Cormac McCarthy. But, I feel like these works aren't about characters so much as they are writing about insight, or about life. Reading them teaches me about universals, not about individual people. The characters often are interchangeable.

That's all fine and good--really, I wouldn't mind writing like Jhumpa Lahiri at all--but if you're after a great character, if you want that person that can't be contained, you must give them the freedom to be stubborn.

In my own experience, I stumbled upon one of my best characters quite on accident. I had written a book told from the point of view of three main characters. But, it wasn't any of these characters that stole the show. It was a stuttering, lanky teenage boy who collected women's underwear and tore the legs off live crabs that everyone said was memorable.

Think about your characters...especially the ones you or others have loved the most. Are they stubborn? Do they make up their own rules regardless of what you'd like them to do?

Monday, May 24, 2010

What You Can't Write About

I heard this idea the other day, and it struck me as useful. It deals with the idea of what writers CAN'T write about. I believe it comes from David Mamet's book Writing in Restaurants, but since I heard it second-hand, I can't say for sure.

So, what can't we write about?

According to this idea, we can't write about conflicts that generally apply to everyone. We can't write about aging, for example. Or homosexuality. Or poverty.

What can we write about?

We can write about choices that characters are making in the face of conflict.

I think this serves to focus our stories and simultaneously make them more emotional and easier to write. A book about aging will probably feel too flat. A book about a character trying to fight aging has the opportunity to carry more personal emotion. Instead of trying to write about the plight of the world, writing about the plight of a small set of characters allows a reader to connect better with the material. Making the subject a personal matter serves to anchor the story, both for the reader and writer.

Do you think about stories this way?

I think as I try to put meaning into my stories, I sometimes get caught up with the idea of trying to write a commentary on a subject. I'll include facts about poverty in third-world countries, or water contamination, or energy consumption. This is probably fine in small quantities, but I think one risks losing their reader if the characters and their journeys are replaced with statistics. Stories can educate readers about subjects without being only about those particular subjects.

Thursday, May 13, 2010

Twilight: by Bella Swan

I can't tell you how many times I've read posts about "characters taking over a story."

Let's think about this - that's just kind of crazy, isn't it? These people don't really exist. Admit it. They don't. No one is taking over your story but you. Only you're writing it - unless you're working on something with multiple authors.

So let's get one thing straight - you can't sit around blaming your characters for things that go wrong. Stop it right now. YOU are in control, and if your story starts going off on some tangent and you think you have to follow because your characters are leading you there, well, you're just being lazy.

Sherrie Peterson wrote an excellent post the other day titled Who's the Boss? Here's a bit of her experience:

Well, I did plenty of flailing. I wrote this weird, melodramatic, dark crap that I hated. I kept thinking if that's where the characters wanted to go, didn't I, as the author, have an obligation to follow them there?

I've decided that way of thinking is wrong, at least for me, and certainly, for this story. My characters are NOT the boss of me.

When it came right down to it, the problem was lack of confidence. I didn't think I was good enough to write the story the way I wanted it to be written, so I fell back on easier solutions. I gave the characters stupid obstacles to overcome and made it too easy for them, for ME, to find a way out. And it was boring. I hated the story so much I put it to the side and worked on other things.

There you go. Sherrie admits that her problem with the story was lack of confidence - and that can easily stray you into lazy-land when it comes to writing. No matter how you look at it, writing a good novel is hard. I remember writing this particular paragraph in my current WIP, a novella about Cinderella:

Rose appeared from the crowd next. Her cheeks mimicked her name. Her fluttering movements made her emerald green dress swish along the floor, and the sound seemed to travel up the material, all the way to Rose’s throat as she curtseyed and said in an airy, billowing voice, “Your Royal Majesties, I am honored that you have allowed us to speak today.” She stood in front of Lucy and Edith now, her tall frame a dark spindly tree between their bright dresses.

I remember thinking at the time - wow, I love Rose! She speaks clearly to me. Introducing her was easy. But why? It's not because she's a living being taking over my manuscript, that's for sure. I remember feeling tempted to put Rose in more scenes. She's Cinderella's stepmother, and in my story, she's only in one scene. She's a strong character, but that doesn't mean I'm going to drop her all over the place whenever I hit a rut. It's tempting, but no.

(1)
Remember that you're in charge of everything. Not critique partners. Not characters. Not all those rules you read about. If you run in a direction that feels like your character is "taking over," understand that, yes, creating a character that comes to life in your mind is fun, but it's still you that created the character, and you have the power to change direction. You certainly don't see Bella Swan's name as the author of Twilight.

(2)
Like I said in Sherrie's comment section on her post, I think we reach a higher level as a writer when we see our work not as set in stone or something out of our control, but as something fluid and flexible and something where we can break the walls down and rebuild and rewrite without ruining anything. When we reach that point, we're really writing, not just spitting out stories in our head.

Wednesday, May 5, 2010

Chrono-illogical?

I admit it. Almost all of the stories I write have back story. Do yours? Generally, I don't have a problem with backstory, but I do think it can become a problem when one always relies on it.

A story that requires backstory hasn't started from the proper beginning. Or, to put it another way, a story with backstory is told out of chronological order.

The reason for writing out of order is most likely because of drama. Either the backstory is so uninteresting that it ends up getting tucked away into other more interesting parts. Or, the backstory is so interesting that it's saved for the climax. In this latter example, the backstory serves to fill in a missing gap in the story, giving the piece as a whole almost a mystery-solving characteristic.

I'm not advocating writing everything in chronological order. Not at all. But, I do think that a story without backstory is a significantly different animal than one that does have it. A story without backstory carries a lot of momentum behind it. The forward-moving timeline really propels the reader forward, and I think it can have a much more exciting feel to it.

I also think that backstory often comes from an attempt to explain a character. In the "literary" character-driven-type story, a character's motivations often stem from some past experience. At least that's how I've used it. But, I wonder if this is also a limitation. It seems to me to be a rather narrow view of psychology when my character eats his lover because of some past break up he had while living in Paris.

What do you all think? Is backstory a weakness? How many of your works don't have backstory? And, most importantly, does it matter?

Monday, April 26, 2010

How Do They Cry?

Knock, knock.

Who's there?

Boo

Boo who?

Why are you crying?

The awkwardness of a crying character came up for me this weekend when I was reading one of my favorite writers and a tear trailed down his character's cheek to the pillow.

I hate it when I describe a tear running down a cheek to a pillow. I hate it when my character's tears well up. Or when my character's choke back a sob. For me, having a character cry is one of the most awkward things I have to write.

So, how do you do it if you do it? Do your characters cry?

Note added later: Check out VR Barkowski's and Michelle's comments on this too.

Monday, April 12, 2010

How Wise Can Our Characters Be?

Today in my writer's group, I was very impressed by something my friend Sue wrote. It was an excerpt about two young people, a girl in high school and a slightly older boy. What astounded me was that these two characters seemed to have two completely different life experiences, and thus two completely different wisdoms. As I was reading about their interaction, I couldn't believe that both of these characters came from a single writer.

This has been something I've tried to do lately in my own writing. I love the idea of having a wise character, or a really intelligent one, but since I'm not all that wise or intelligent myself, I sometimes feel like it's impossible to write about anyone better than I am in a convincing way. Could I, for example, write about a math genius? Probably not. Yet, I hate the idea that all of my characters must by default be less than or equal to myself in those departments.

Is it possible to write about a character wiser or more intelligent than yourself? If you've done it, how did you manage it?

Note added later: As so often happens, one of the comments made my point far better than I did. I think along with the question of the wisdom of a character being greater than the writer's, I wonder if a writer can write about two different wise people and have them actually be different. Take a look at Judith Mercado's comment.

Tuesday, February 16, 2010

My Hero Wrote This Chapter

Here's a little experiment you might want to try for whatever it is you're currently writing (or revising). Imagine that your protagonist and your antagonist are each writing their own version of the final chapter of the book (or the final paragraph of the story, if you aren't writing a novel). Ask yourself how they would write that chapter--what they want that chapter to contain. Then, go back through the story and every time your protagonist or antagonist makes a choice, see to it that the choice they make would be in line with that chapter/paragraph they'd have written. If they are making choices that would lead them away from their visions of the book/story outcome, then you either have some rewriting or some explaining to do. Don't take this to mean that your characters have to always be making the right decisions; but people in general think they're making the right decisions to get what they want. Don't take this to mean that your protagonist or antagonist will be able to predict the actual outcome of the book/story, either. Either or both of them will be wrong.

This isn't something you need to be able to do when you first sit down writing. So back off, pantsters! But it is a question that you'll have to be able to answer at some point before you can declare that your book/story is finished.

I also recognize that not all stories are about achieving specific goals or acquiring people/places/things or defeating/surviving enemies/adversity. Yes, I know this because I'm fairly widely read. But the thing is, if you are writing a story, then there is likely going to be some change in the main character's life, and that character will be interested in and have an opinion about that outcome.

Tuesday, January 12, 2010

Also Known As

Here's a short experiment, no eye protection or heat-resistant gloves needed. Some of you may have seen this one before, but please bear with me anyway.

Take a sheet of paper (or a Post-it or an index card, or whatever). Write your name on the paper. Turn the paper over and, on the other side, write an alias for yourself. It has to be a brand-new pseudonym, not a childhood nickname or anything anyone else has ever called you. Take as long as you need; I'll wait right here for you to finish. But try to do it in less than a minute, just because I know that you haven't got all day. And, you know, this assignment isn't part of your grade.

Done? I chose "Asimov Eric Crane." I have no idea why, and that's not the point.

Do you remember the moment when you turned over the paper and stared off into space and there was nothing but a blank gray wall before your mind's eye and you didn't know the answer to the question yet? You were sitting in a sort of undefined space where there was only one wrong answer, and it was written on the down-facing side of your paper. That moment was a real, palpable moment of creativity and, more importantly, an example of writing what you don't know.

When I did this exercise, I felt--though just for a few seconds--disoriented and off-balance and, honestly, a bit afraid and verging on nausea. Call me a wimp; I've been called worse, trust me. One thing that was going on in my mind during that moment of off-balance creativity was a battle between conflicting forces: You are this alias. No, you are this one instead. No, over here is your real alias. There were several directions I could've gone, and in that brief moment I was aware of, if not every possibile outcome to my creative problem, at least many of them. The more complex the creative problem and the more time we allow ourselves to think about the solutions, the more possibilities we'll see. Most of those possibilities will conflict with each other, and we will attempt to choose one of them and let the others go.

Some of the most interesting and useful things we can discover about our story elements (characters, scenes, plots, themes) are the conflicting versions of them that are possible. One of the things I've tried to do in my own fiction is to present many of the conflicting versions of story elements in the same story. It has only been recently that I realized I was doing this, or perhaps it's more accurate to say that it's only been recently that I started trying to give a name to what I've been doing in stories. But as I say, if there is more than one way to think about some story element, I am pretty strongly inclined to include more than one of those ways in my stories. I'll give an easy example, using something I did in a chapter of my WIP "Cocke & Bull."

Suppose you have a group of characters who've all traveled to a city together. Suppose there is some kind of emotional turmoil or conflict within the group. Suppose you want to have your characters walk through the city from one setting to another, and you want to point out locations in the city. Suppose you also want to show the emotional turmoil, but you don't just want them to argue their way across town.

What I did was split the group in two, and the first group walks through the city and I give their impressions of the various locations within it, and I show certain interactions they have with the city's inhabitants. I use a certain type of images and descriptive language, to paint things as colorful and fun and light-hearted. Then I have the second group walk through the city, following the same path as the first group, and I show their interactions with the city's inhabitants. I use a different set of images and type of descriptive language for this trip, painting the city as dark, shabby, dangerous. It is the same city, but viewed from a different emotional angle, as it were.

This is one of my current favorite tricks, and in "Cocke & Bull" and my last book, I've played scenes twice in a row and shown how the scene can have radically different meanings depending on how you interpret the actions within the scene.

A sort of inverse to this is to figure out what the your characters' best and worst traits are, and to dramatize them behaving at their best and their worst in scenes that are as similar as you can make them. Show us your hero, and then show us his alias, as it were. Think, for example, of the protagonist's thoughtless insult during the garden party in Jane Austen's Emma. Shocking, embarrassing, and totally believable. Let the reader enter that moment of off-balance creativity you had, and let the reader be caught up in the battle between conflicting forces inside the story and the characters. You can ask youself "What are the possibilities here?" and you can use more than one answer. You can stay in that off-balance moment of creativity and write down as many aliases as you like and call them all the right answers.

My point, if I have one and possibly I really don't, is that rather than choose The One True Way for your characters and stories, you can create a multiplicity of meanings for events and people and places that are all true and all overlap and all conflict with one another and the story will be, in my opinion, much deeper and richer and satisfying. You can show, with certainty, that the world is uncertain. You can define how things are not definite. You can give your characters and your story not one alias, but many.

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Making A Scene

I am currently working on the middle section (or Act Two, if you use the three-act structure) of my novel-in-progress, Cocke & Bull. This section essentially does one thing: it leads up to a climactic emotional moment between two of the main characters to resolve a conflict that began at the end of Act One, the resolution of which conflict will lead to the climax in Act Three which deals with the conflict that started off the story. If that makes no sense, imagine the story as a conflict/climax within another conflict/climax. Conflict 1 is the story's outer problem, and Conflict 2 is the story's inner problem:

Act 1:
CONFLICT 1 begins
CONFLICT 2 begins
Act 2:
CONFLICT 2 climaxes
Act 3:
CONFLICT 1 climaxes

I'm very happy with this overall structure and I may just use it for every novel I write from here on out. Unless I don't. I'm capricious that way. Anyway.

The emotional climax at the end of Act 2 is a big moment in the story, making the climax in Act 3 inevitable. So I need to have this emotional climax really stand out and I have to lead into it well. I'm going to use an idea that I got from reading "The Art of Subtext" by Charles Baxter. In this book, Baxter talks about how in real life, most people avoid "making a scene." Most people bite back their strongest emotions and try hard not to bare their souls. There are things we would love to do, but we do not do them because such things are not done or because the price we'd pay for these acts would be too high.

For example, imagine two men. Let's call them Andy and Tom and let's say they work together in a large office. Tom's the sort of guy who objectifies women and is obsessed with the size of their breasts. In fact, one of his habits is to whisper his estimate of women's breast sizes to Andy whenever they're together. "Check it out," Tom will say. "38D!" He also gives nicknames to the women who work in the office with him and Andy. These nicknames all have to do with the women's breasts and are, of course, private and only used by Tom when speaking to Andy.

Andy is uncomfortable with this, but when he was first getting to know Tom, he said nothing about this behavior and subsequently it's only gotten worse as time goes on and now what Andy wants is for Tom to just leave him alone. But it's awkward. They work together on some of the same projects, and frankly Andy isn't sure how to bring the subject and his objections up. It's outside of his comfort zone. He doesn't want to make a scene at the office.

If this were the basis of a story, the climax of it would be Andy, finally unable to hold his tongue, busting out with a highly-emotional demand that Tom shut up about their coworkers' physiques and, you know, we're just not going to be friends anymore so just leave me alone. Andy will let out all this bottled-up frustration and embarrassment, unleashing it on Tom in a compressed moment, preferably in a too-small physical space like an elevator or a supply room or something, because small spaces increase emotional force. What happens after the climax will depend on if Andy or Tom is the protagonist, and that's not really the point here.

Leading up to the moment when Andy makes a scene, we'll need scenes that increase the tension between him and Tom, with Andy biting back words and being increasingly embarrassed by the whole thing. We'll have to make it clear that the one thing Andy would love to do is tell Tom to shut up (hey, maybe Tom is Andy's superior or team leader or something?), and make it clear that Andy would never do this, and then have Andy do it anyway. That's drama, folks. The conflict and tension increase over time and then are paid off in the climax.

So in my own book, I've got a character who knows that the real solution to the inner conflict of the story (Conflict 2 in my chart above) is an act that he will no way never commit. So what I'm doing now is having him fight against his urge to commit that act, putting in scenes where it will look as if that act won't be necessary and then...oh, gosh I guess it will be after all. He's faced with the decision to solve his problem and pay a very high price, or not solve his problem and live with a misery more-or-less of his own making (because the drama is better when the crisis has been brought about by the character himself).

Anyway, I just wanted to talk about this idea of "making a scene" and how the common-enough situation of demonstrating admirable restraint when we'd rather not can be the model for larger emotional movements in novels. It's a new way of seeing the dramatic arc for me, so I'm sharing. Also, this is my way of recommending Baxter's book: The Art of Subtext: Beyond Plot.

Thursday, December 10, 2009

Your Character is Wrong

Andrew Rosenberg is an aspiring author hailing from the Sasquatch-infested woods of the Great Northwest. He is currently working on his latest WIP, a Steampunk novel known as Steam Palace, in which his main character uncovers her family's deep dark secret and realizes she has been terribly wrong about her life and her ideals.

We'd like to thank Andrew for this guest post today. It's worth reading! You can visit him at his blog, The Write Runner.

~~~~~

Let me paint a picture. We’ll discuss it, then I’ll show you how your character is wrong.

You wake up in the morning. What do you do? Brush your teeth? Take a shower? Make breakfast?

Why not brush your dog? Take a nap? Make dinner?

Sounds silly at first, but what happens is that you make choices. You decide what is important to you at every moment, weigh the alternatives, and make a choice. At every moment of life, we have an infinite number of choices. We think we know what the consequences are of each choice. If we brush our teeth, then we have clean breath and an unkempt dog. But if we brush the dog, then we have a nice puppy but bad breath. Choices.

Some choices are not so obvious, especially when emotions are involved. These are the decisions that people spend a lot of energy thinking about. Whom do we ask out and how? When do we break up or quit our job? Which college is the right one? Should I enlist? People agonize over these choices because the consequences of a bad choice can be painful if not outright deadly.

I read a snippet of someone’s WIP the other day. It included a line something to the effect of “She hated the way he made her feel.”

Here’s the thing. There are no wires attached to your brain and no strings attached to your arms and legs. Nobody is controlling your emotions through some external means. You have eyes, ears, a nose, a tongue, and skin. All these organs generate electro-chemical impulses that are fairly indistinguishable from each other. These signals enter your brain which then decides what those impulses mean. A bunch of neurons fire in your ear, which activates your brain, which interprets those impulses into words, which (according to your X years of life on Earth) you decide means someone is saying something, and that something is hurtful. You’ve wired your own brain to decide what something means. No one can make you feel anything. You’ve chosen the meaning based on your experience and your beliefs about that person and the words that are said.

Here’s the next thing. You decide how your brain is wired (mostly). Your brain is not a computer with X number of transistors. You decide how to decode external stimuli. You make choices based on these stimuli. At some point, you may suddenly make a new choice, given the same external input. How does this happen? You choose to interpret things differently. The process in which you choose new interpretations is called learning. It’s the process in which people change and grow. Inside your brain, the neurons are always changing, creating new connections and severing old ones. You decide which connections are important, and which ones you choose to drop.

This is the key to successful story writing. Your character starts out with a certain world view. They make the same choices given the same external stimuli. This view does not serve them, given an unbiased external analysis, and especially as the story moves forward and they face greater and greater obstacles. Characters are locked into their world view because it’s all they’ve known, and they’ve rejected anything outside this view. They fight to protect this world view, because what does the alternative mean? What would it mean to find out that their belief system is incomplete or flawed? What would they discover if those same hurtful words they hear became helpful or even a revelation?

It would mean that they were wrong. Nobody wants to admit they are wrong, or ignorant, or mistaken. More than that, they would have to see that they were wrong about their interpretation of the most important event of their lives, whether this event happens in the backstory or in the first act. Their conclusions were wrong, and every choice they made based on this conclusion was probably based on faulty logic. The best episode on the TV series “Happy Days” is when The Fonz(Henry Winkler) has to apologize to Richie Cunningham(Ron Howard). He’s established his entire world view on being “cool”, or being tough and unrepentant. He must learn that even the great Arthur Fonzarelli makes mistakes. He finally explains, “Cool is knowing the difference between right and wrong and doing what is right with guts.” He has a new interpretation of the word “cool”. He was wrong, and once he realizes this, his whole life changes and he now has the power to conquer his foes.

A good story should rip apart the character’s world view. But characters shouldn’t go down without a fight. The biggest and most important battle a character fights is not with the antagonist. The villain is simply there to point out the character’s weaknesses, to show them where they’ve been wrong. In fact, there’s no way to defeat the villain while clinging to their old world view. The villain uses this knowledge to their advantage. It’s not until the character learns a new interpretation of their defining event and beliefs that they can defeat the villain, and the old demons in their head. It’s the moment where they say, “I’m not this weak/boring/unlovable/unworthy/untalented/indecisive/fearful person. I’m a mighty/fascinating/cherished/deserving/inspired/assertive/brave man/woman and I’m kicking ass!”

So here are the questions you should ask yourself when reviewing your story:

    1. What critical event occurred in your character’s life (usually in childhood) and what decision did they make about themselves based on that event?

    2. How does it affect their world view?How does this negatively impact them in the present (the start of the novel)? How does it hold them back?

    3. How does this world view impact their ability to work through the central crisis of the novel?

    4. What do they learn about this critical event in their past? What new interpretation do they have? How does this affect their choices moving forward?

    5. How does this help them confront the antagonist and prevail in the end?